skip to content
✨ Enjoy 2 Free Months of Rent on Us on Select Units! We are Minutes from Liberty & Monticello NY✨
Sullivan County Courthouse in Monticello NY

Your Go-To Guide for Exploring Monticello, NY

Tucked in the heart of the Catskills, Monticello, NY, is a town filled with history and culture. About half way between Binghamton and New York City, you will find beautiful scenery and a wonderful community to call home. Whether you’re looking for excellent dining, entertainment, outdoor adventures, or educational opportunities, Monticello has something for everyone. This guide will take you through the highlights of what makes the town a unique destination.


Table of Contents

I. About Monticello, NY

II. Attractions & Dining


Welcome to the Village of Monticello, NY

Located in Sullivan County, the town was founded in the early 19th century. It was named after Thomas Jefferson’s Virginia estate—reflecting the early American admiration for Jeffersonian ideals. The village was incorporated in 1830, and its establishment was largely due to the vision of John Patterson Jones, who played a significant role in its development.

Monticello is well-known for its role in the Catskills’ resort boom during the 20th century. Starting in the 1920s, the area became a popular destination for city dwellers looking to escape the heat and hustle of New York City. The construction of luxurious hotels, such as the Concord Resort Hotel and Kutsher’s Hotel, drew thousands of visitors each summer.

Today, Monticello continues to attract visitors and residents with its charming blend of history and modernity. The village is home to the Resorts World Catskills casino, which opened in 2018 and has become a significant economic driver for the area. It offers a world-class casino experience. With over 100,000 square feet of gaming space, including slot machines, table games, and a poker room, this casino promises an unforgettable experience. The resort also features fine dining, entertainment, and luxurious accommodations.

Community Resources: New Resident 101

Education

Monticello is home to several educational institutions that provide quality education and enrichment opportunities. The Monticello Central School District serves the town and surrounding areas, offering comprehensive educational programs from pre-kindergarten through 12th grade. The district is committed to academic excellence and provides a range of extracurricular activities. For continued education, nearby SUNY Sullivan is a community college that offers a variety of degree programs and continuing education opportunities.

Healthcare

You have several healthcare options to ensure you have access to quality medical care. Garnet Health Medical Center – Catskills is a major facility in the area providing comprehensive medical services, including emergency care, outpatient services, and specialized treatments. Additionally, there are various clinics and private practices offering primary care, dental services, and specialist consultations.

 

Get to Know & Explore Monticello

Cultural & Recreational Attractions

Whether you’re a music lover, theater enthusiast, car aficionado, or sports fan, Monticello has something for you. Discover the attractions that make Monticello special.

  • Bethel Woods Center for the Arts: Just a short drive from Monticello, the Bethel Woods Center for the Arts is a premier venue for concerts and cultural events. Located on the historic site of the 1969 Woodstock Festival, this center hosts a wide range of performances, including rock, classical, and country music.
  • Monticello Motor Club: For car enthusiasts, the Monticello Motor Club offers an exclusive experience. This private automotive country club features a world-class racing circuit and provides driving experiences, track days, and high-performance driving instruction.
  • Forestburgh Playhouse: The Forestburgh Playhouse, located just a short drive from Monticello, is one of the oldest summer theaters in the country. It offers a variety of performances, including Broadway musicals, plays, and cabaret shows, in an intimate and charming setting.
  • Monticello Raceway: Established in 1958, Monticello Raceway is a historic harness racing track. It offers exciting live standardbred horse races and simulcast racing from tracks nationwide, along with on-site dining facilities for a complete entertainment experience.

Wildlife & Outdoor Adventures

Monticello’s natural beauty makes it a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. From hiking to fishing, there’s no shortage of ways to enjoy the great outdoors.

  • Mongaup Valley Wildlife Management AreaThis expansive area offers a variety of outdoor activities, including hiking, bird watching, and fishing. The scenic trails provide stunning views of the surrounding landscape, and the area is home to a diverse range of wildlife.
  • Holiday Mountain Ski & Fun Park: During the winter months, Holiday Mountain Ski & Fun Park is a popular destination for skiing and snowboarding. In the summer, the park offers go-kart racing, mini-golf, and other family-friendly activities.

Dining for Every Taste

The village offers a fairly diverse array of dining options. From casual eateries to unique cuisine combinations, the town’s culinary scene is sure to satisfy.

  • Miss Monticello Diner: A local favorite, Miss Monticello Diner serves classic American diner fare. Known for its hearty breakfasts and friendly service, this diner is a perfect spot to start your day.
  • Albella Restaurant: For those craving Italian cuisine, Albella Restaurant is a must-visit. The menu features traditional dishes like pasta, pizza, and seafood, all prepared with fresh ingredients. The cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal place for a family dinner or a romantic evening.
  • Yanni’s Gyro Express Café: If you’re in the mood for something quick and delicious, Yanni’s Gyro Express Cafe offers a variety of Greek-inspired dishes. Their gyros and souvlaki are particularly popular, offering a taste of the Mediterranean in the heart of Monticello.
  • Annie’s HomeStyle Kitchen: This diner on Broadway is known for its Southern-style soul food, including fried chicken, potato salads, and buffalo wings. The cozy setting, complete with a fireplace, and excellent service make Annie’s a favorite for both locals and visitors​
  • Salt and Pepper Kitchen: Offering a mix of Korean and American staples, Salt and Pepper Kitchen is the place to go for delicious bulgogi sandwiches and other tasty dishes.

Moving to Monticello with Bethel Self Storage Park

Monticello offers a little bit of everything. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a delicious meal, experience live entertainment, explore the great outdoors, or simply relax and unwind, Monticello has it all. It’s no wonder the area continues to be a beloved destination for both residents and visitors alike. So come and discover all that Monticello has to offer—you won’t be disappointed.

If you are moving to the area, keep it simple by storing your belongings with Bethel Self Storage Park. From the initial move to organizing your home, we are here to support you as you need some extra space. Stop into our Bethel storage facility to find an affordable solution for your storage load, or find a storage unit online!

Rent Now Button


Bella author photo

Bella Quill

About the Author: Bella Quill is a Marketing Intern at Storage Asset Management. She is exploring all parts or marketing, including content writing and social media. In Bella's free time, she loves to travel, bake, and spend time with her horse, Sunny.